We Shall Overcome

Frank Hamilton remembers Zilphia Horton, Guy Carawan, Pete Seeger and “We Shall Overcome"

from an interview with Frank Hamilton April 1, 2014 in Lexington KY

FRANK HAMILTON: I first heard the song in Topanga Canyon, California up at the Will Geer ranch. And there were kids from the Highlander Folk School in Tennessee that came over who had learned the song from Zilphia Horton. Ziphia Horton was married to Myles Horton who was the head of the Highlander Folk School, a very important institution. And they had sung the song and I listened to it and thought to myself, “That’s a very nice song, but it needs something.”


Now Pete had put that song into The People’s Songbook back in the 1940s, and it was called "We Will Overcome," and he had learned it from the striking tobacco workers in North Carolina. So that’s the song that the kids were singing when they came from Highlander up into Topanga.

At that time I had been attending the St. Paul Baptist Church in Los Angeles on Central Avenue. St. Paul’s had a one hundred piece choir, a Black choir, singing songs like “Precious Memories How They Linger,” and they had this very strong Gospel rhythm.

And I remember hearing that organ roll and that one hundred piece choir. It was so impressive I took Pete Seeger down there.

I just loved the music. I heard about it on the radio, at the end of the dial. That’s where you heard the “good” music.


MARK DVORAK: So you went to St. Paul’s on a Sunday to hear the music at the church service?


FH: Oh yeah! Absolutely! It was really quite an experience because this group, this hundred piece choir and that organ player, they just filled that cavernous sanctuary which had neon crosses and the glitz and everything. The matrons were all dressed in white, and the people would freak out. They’d find Jesus and they’d get down on their knees. They’d roll around on the floor and holler and yell. Then everybody would go out after that and have Sunday morning breakfast.

And I thought, “My goodness, that’s an interesting form of psychotherapy.” I’d never thought about it that way.

So Pete had added this song in The People’s Songbook in the 1940s. He was aware of the song then, when it was called “We Will Overcome.” And it was sung in a very sing-songy way in 6/8 time. And this is the way the Highlander Center kids also sang it when I heard them in Topanga Canyon.

I want to say this was 1954 or 55. Somewhere in that area. And when I remembered hearing the hundred piece choir at St. Paul’s sing “Precious Memories,” I also recalled the distinct rhythm that they put to the melody and thought, “That’s the ingredient that’s missing in the way the kids were singing “We Will Overcome.”

So I started messing with the chords and began jamming with the tune, trying to get the chords down and the rhythm that I remembered hearing at St.Paul’s.

By then I was singing at parties in the Los Angeles area and slowly it all began to come together. 


One day Guy Carawan called me up on the telephone and he says, “Hey, I heard you singing this song and I want to learn it.”

Guy and I grew up in Los Angeles and we were singing partners for a while. Guy was a very handsome young man with a beautiful tenor voice. He went to John Marshall High School and wore white buck shoes and his letter sweater.

Guy would sing show songs like “Hello Young Lovers” and play it on his ukulele. This was in the 1950s. So Guy wanted to learn this song from me. And I gave him the chords and tried to show him the feel I thought the song should have. Guy learned it and he took it with him when he went to Greensboro, North Carolina for the first sit-in movement. This was the first major Civil Rights demonstration. It was a lunch counter sit-in that took place around 1960.

Guy sang “We Will Overcome” to everyone at the demonstration and as I understand it, they began to request it because they wanted to learn it. 

220px-Pete Seeger Stern Grove

Then Pete got back into the picture and decided that he was going to change “we will overcome” to we shall overcome.”

I thought this was only okay. I didn’t think it was brilliant. Pete thought that “shall” sang better but I thought and still think that “will” is a stronger word than “shall.”

Lillian Hellman the great playwright, who wrote Watch on the Rhine and Little Foxes, said about the song, “What do you mean, ‘someday?’ How about ‘right now!’” So that’s where I changed it. I sang, “we will overcome, today!”

And then I added “we are not afraid.” The Klu Klux Klan came and literally burned down the Highlander Folk School in Monteagle, Tennessee. The school finally moved to New Market, Tennessee.

Guy popularized the song. And when the Black people heard that Gospel thing in the rhythm, they identified with it. They said, “That’s our song.” And Guy had the musicianship to pull it off. He delivered it with the 12/8 feel.

So what happened there, was that Pete thought he had taught the song to Guy. And I had to remind him, “No you didn’t teach it to Guy. I taught it to Guy.” Pete did not know the version that Guy brought to the sit-in in Greensboro, North Carolina. He did not.”

MD: Was Pete actively singing “We Will Overcome” when he put it in The People’s Songbook?

FH: Yes his knew it and was actively singing it, but he didn’t sing it with the Gospel feel. He was singing it straight 6/8 and kind of white, is all I can say about it. It wasn’t a big song then. Nobody thought very much of it.

MD: So now we’re in the 1960s and the song has taken on a life of its own. The African-American people who were active in the Civil Rights movement adopted it as a theme song…

FH: That’s right. Bernice Reagon and the Civil Rights singers, I’ve forgotten all their names now, but they all sang it. And they toured singing it. And then of course it found its way into the churches throughout the South.

MD: I had heard a story where Pete had come to Highlander Center in the 1960s during Civil Rights when Highlander became a gathering place and a refuge for people who were marching. And Pete heard people singing the song there, and that’s when he rediscovered it.

FH: That’s right. He rediscovered it.

MD: With the Gospel feel…

FH: With the Black feel.

MD: Is that when Pete added to his repertoire?

FH: That’s right. He began singing it exactly with what we had put into it. And that’s the story of “We Shall Overcome.”

MD: The composer credits for the song are Pete Seeger, Zilphia Horton, Guy Carawan and Frank Hamilton. How did it come to be that there are four people credited with the composition?


FH: Well, I taught it to Guy and Guy got me on the copyright. Pete went along with it apparently because he knew Guy. And that was my contribution, anyway. Guy put me on the copyright, sent me the release forms and I said, “sure,” and that was it.

MD: Do you earn any residuals from the song?

FH: No. What happened was Pete sent me a form that said this song really belongs to the Black people. Originally they wanted the money to go to Dr. King’s organization, the Southern Christian Leadership Council. So that’s where the money went and I signed my share over to them. Then Highlander took over when the SCLC dissolved. So the money went to finance Highlander. And I thought that was really appropriate and that’s the way it should be. So I never made a lot of money from the song. Nobody got rich from that song.

MD: Well, we all got rich on that song!

FH: Yes of course, we all got rich on that song. When people ask me if I wrote the song, I say, “No of course not.”

But I was part of it. It’s a folk song because it was made by many hands, sung by a lot of voices. It’s an important song in American history and the real important thing is that it doesn’t belong to anybody. “We Shall Overcome” belongs to everybody.


Click on the image to download and print the Frank Hamilton’s chord progression to “We Shall Overcome." 


Click on the image to listen “We Shall Overcome” from the book/CD compilation Sing For Freedom: The Story of the Civil Rights Movement through its songs by Guy and Candie Carawan.

Stay in touch • info AT markdvorak.com • PO Box 181 • Brookfield IL 60513 • 312 315 4273